Quantitative Research In Education Reading Answer Passage
Quantitative Research In Education Reading Answer Passage
Paragraph A. The first area of criticism concerns the extent to which the results of ‘scientific’ educational research are valid. It has often been argued that, although the numerical evidence produced by such research has the appearance of being ‘ hard data’ of the kind used in the natural sciences, there are, in fact, fundamental doubts about its validity, about whether it accurately represents what it claims to represent. We can get a sense of these criticisms by looking briefly at the work of Piaget, mentioned earlier. Interestingly, this was not strongly quantitative in character, and it has been criticised by some for being insufficiently rigorous from an experimental point of view, reflecting, at least in part, a difference between Piaget and commentators on his work about the requirements of scientific research. This highlights the point we made earlier: that although it is convenient to refer to the ‘scientific method’, there is, in fact, a variety of interpretations of what is involved in a scientific approach to research and of how it should be applied to the study of human beings and their behaviours.
Paragraph B. Piaget carried out a number of experiments on the basis of which he developed the idea that children go through different stages of development and that only when they have reached the necessary stage of development can they carry out the most advanced forms of cognitive operation. A famous experiment of his required children to compare the amount of liquid held by different-shaped containers. The containers had the same capacity, and even when young children were shown that the same amount of liquid could be poured between the two containers, many claimed that one was larger than the other. Piaget’s interpretation of this was that the children were unable to perform the logical task involved in recognising that the two containers, while different in shape, were the same in capacity; this being because their cognitive development had not reached the necessary stage. Critics of his work have questioned this conclusion, for instance, Donaldson. They raise the possibility that the children were simply unwilling to play the experimenter’s game, or that the children misunderstood what the experimenter was asking. These criticisms point to the fact, obvious enough, but important in its implications, that experiments are social situations in which interpersonal interactions take place. The implication is that Piaget’s work and attempts to replicate it are not only measuring the children’s capacities for logical thinking, but also the extent to which they have understood what was required, their willingness to comply with these requirements, the experimenters’ success in communicating what was required, in motivating the children, etc.
Paragraph C. Similar criticisms have been applied to psychological and educational tests. For example, Mehan points out how test questions may be interpreted in ways different from those intended by the researcher. In all language development tests, children are presented with a picture of a medieval fortress, complete with moat, drawbridge, and parapets and three initial consonants: D, C, and G. The child is supposed to circle the correct initial consonant C for ‘castle’ is correct, but many children choose D. After the test, when I asked those children what the name of the building was, they responded ‘Disneyland’. These children used the same line of reasoning intended by the tester, but they arrived at the wrong substantive answer. The score sheet showing a wrong answer does not document a child’s lack of reasoning ability; it only documents that the child indicated an answer different from the one the tester expected.
Paragraph D. Here we have questions being raised about the validity of the sort of measurements on which the findings of quantitative research are typically based. Some, including, for example Donaldson, regard these as technical problems that can be overcome by more rigorous experimentation. Others, however, including Mehan, believe them to be not simply problems with particular experiments or tests, but serious threats to validity that potentially affect all research of this kind.
Paragraph E. At the same time, questions have also been raised about the assumption built into the logic of quantitative educational research that causes can be identified by physical and/or statistical manipulation of variables. Critics suggest that this fails to take account of the very nature of human social life, assuming it to consist of fixed, mechanical causal relationships, whereas, in fact, it involves complex processes of interpretation and negotiation that do not have determinate outcomes. From this point of view, it is not clear that we can understand why people do what they do in terms of the simple sorts of causal relationships on which quantitative research focuses. Social life, it is suggested, is much more contextually variable and complex.
Paragraph F. Such criticisms of quantitative educational research have been the stimulus for an increasing number of educational researchers, over the past thirty or forty years, to adopt more qualitative approaches. These researchers have generally rejected attempts to measure and control variables experimentally or statistically. Qualitative research can take many forms; loosely indicated by such terms as ‘ethnography’, ‘case study’, ‘participant observation’, ‘life history’, ‘unstructured interviewing’, ‘discourse analysis’, etc. In general, though, it has the following characteristics:
Paragraph G. A strong emphasis on exploring the nature of particular educational phenomena, rather than setting out to test hypotheses about them. A tendency to work with ‘unstructured data’: that is, data that have not been coded at the point of collection in terms of a closed set of analytical categories. When engaging in observation, qualitative researchers, therefore, audio- or video-record what happens or write detailed open-ended field notes, rather than coding behaviour in terms of a predefined set of categories, as would a quantitative researcher employing ‘systematic observation’. Similarly when interviewing, open-ended questions will be asked rather than questions requiring predefined answers of the kind typical, for example, of postal questionnaires. In fact, qualitative interviews are often designed to be close in character to casual conversations.
Paragraph H. Typically, a small number of cases will be investigated in detail, rather than any attempt being made to cover a large number, as would be the case in most quantitative research, such as systematic observational studies or social surveys. The analysis of the data involves explicit interpretations of the meanings and functions of human actions, and mainly takes the form of verbal descriptions and explanations. Quantification and statistical analysis play a subordinate role at most. The two areas of educational research where criticism of quantitative research and the development of qualitative approaches initially emerged most strongly were the sociology of education and evaluation studies. The trend towards qualitative research in the sociology of education began in the UK in the l960s with studies of a boys’ grammar school, a boys’ secondary modern school, and a girls’ grammar school by Lacey, Hargreaves and Lambart. They employed an ethnographic or participant observation approach, though they also collected some quantitative data on, for example, friendship patterns among the pupils. These researchers observed lessons, interviewed teachers and pupils, and drew on school records. They studied the schools for relatively long periods, spending many months collecting data and tracking changes over time.
Let’s explore the questions and answers of the Quantitative Research In Education reading answer passage.
Quantitative Research In Education Reading Answers with Sample Questions
Have you read the passage? Now, take the test and find the Quantitative Research In Education Reading answers! Try to answer these questions by yourself before you sneak a peek at the answers given below.
Check Out Top 65+ IELTS Reading Practice Test Questions with Answers
Below are some top 65+ free IELTS Reading Practice test online questions with detailed answers to enhance your IELTS preparation online. We have provided sample passages for each test type for your reference.
- The Step Pyramid Of Djoser Reading Answers
- South Pole Adventurer Reading Answers
- The Future Of Work Reading Answers
- Ambergris Reading Answers
- Trees In Trouble Reading Answers
- Could Urban Engineers Learn From Dance Reading Answers
- The Flavour Of Pleasure Reading Answers
- The Value Of A College Degree Reading Answers
- Why You Should Delegate Tasks To Team Members Reading Answers
- Corporate Social Responsibility Reading Answers
- Forest Management In Pennsylvania USA Reading Answers
- Making Time For Science Reading Answers
- The Power Of Play Reading Answers
- Coastal Archaeology Of Britain Reading Answers
- How The Other Half Thinks Reading Answers
- Changes In Reading Habits Reading Answers
- The Forgotten Forest Reading Answers
- When Conversations Flow Reading Answers
- Attitudes Towards Artificial Intelligence Reading Answers
- The Ingenuity Gap Reading Answers
- A Bar At The Folies Reading Answers
- Booking A Wessex Cottages Holiday Reading Answers
- Sunset Tours Reading Answers
- Bird Migration Reading Answers
- Clutter Bugs Beware Reading Answers
- The Hidden Histories Of Exploration Exhibition Reading Answers
- Calisthenics Reading Answers
- Having A Lovely Time Reading Answers
- The Return Of Huarango Reading Answers
- Summer Activities At London Kew Gardens Reading Answers
- Computer Games For Preschoolers Reading Answers
- Extinct The Giant Deer Reading Answers
- Micro Enterprise Credit For Street Youth Reading Answers
- Plain English Campaign Reading Answers
- Glow Worms Reading Answers
- How To Prepare For An Interview Reading Answers
- Quiet Roads Ahead Reading Answers
- Sculpture Reading Answers
- Cornwall Reading Answers
- Latchkey Children Reading Answers
- Healthy Intentions Reading Answers
- Makete Integrated Rural Transport Project Reading Answers
- Allergy Testing Reading Answers
- Life Casting And Art Reading Answers
- Metropolis Movies Reading Answers
- The Bridge That Swayed Reading Answers
- The Discovery Of Uranus Reading Answers
- The Extraordinary Watkin Tench Reading Answers
- The Secret Schizoid Reading Answers
- The Sun A Mixed Blessing Reading Answers
- Urban Planning In Singapore Reading Answers
- Why Risks Can Go Wrong Reading Answers
- Your Moulex Iron Reading Answers
- The Harbour View Hotel Reading Answers
- The Exploration Of Mars Reading Answers
- The Luddites Reading Answers
- Eco Resort Management Reading Answers
- Finding Our Way Reading Answers
- Language Diversity Reading Answers
- Martin Luther King Reading Answers
- One Hundred Days Of Reform Reading Answers
- Private Schools Reading Answers


